Individual Stocks vs Mutual Funds and ETFs

April 24, 2024

Today, I’m excited to delve into a topic that’s unique to how we manage accounts as we talk about the rationale behind building our portfolios primarily with individual stocks rather than mutual funds.

Guy kicks things off by emphasizing the importance of understanding the nuances between individual stocks, mutual funds, and ETFs. While mutual funds and ETFs offer diversification benefits, especially for smaller accounts or within qualified plans, they come with certain limitations. Mutual funds, in particular, are constrained by their prospectus mandates, leading to less flexibility in managing through market volatility.

One of the key advantages of individual stocks lies in the ability to tailor portfolios to specific risk profiles and market conditions. Unlike mutual funds, which often chase performance in favorable market environments, individual stock portfolios can be strategically positioned to minimize downside risk while maximizing upside potential.
Guy highlights the significance of risk-adjusted returns, which essentially entail achieving desired returns while mitigating risk exposure. This entails a delicate balance of participating in market growth while safeguarding against downturns. By actively managing individual stock holdings, our team can navigate turbulent market phases with greater agility and precision.
Moreover, tax efficiency emerges as a crucial consideration, particularly for non-tax-sheltered accounts. Mutual funds are prone to capital gain distributions, driven by forced selling during market downturns or sector rotations. In contrast, individual stock portfolios offer the flexibility to harvest tax losses, optimize gains, and strategically manage tax liabilities. (learn more about this in our Tax Planning and Invest video part 1
ETFs, while offering diversification benefits, can exhibit concentration risks, especially in cap-weighted indexes. This concentration can compromise portfolio diversification and expose investors to heightened volatility. By building portfolios with individual stocks, we can maintain a balanced and diversified portfolio without succumbing to undue concentration risks.
In essence, the decision to prioritize individual stocks over mutual funds reflects our commitment to delivering superior risk-adjusted returns, optimizing tax efficiency, and maintaining flexibility in portfolio management. Whether it’s capitalizing on market opportunities, mitigating downside risks, or optimizing tax outcomes, individual stocks offer a versatile and dynamic approach to portfolio construction.
As Guy and I wrap up our discussion, we invite you to explore these concepts further and reach out with any questions or inquiries. We’re here to guide you through the intricacies of portfolio management and help you achieve the financial security you seek.

If you’d like to schedule a personal one-on-one call with Michelle, click HERE to access Michelle’s calendar and schedule a day and time that is convenient for you.

We serve clients in Mineral Point WI, Dodgeville WI, Platteville WI, Lancaster WI, Fennimore WI, Boscobel WI, Richland Center WI, Muscoda WI, Spring Green WI, Mazomanie WI, Sauk City WI, Middleton WI, Madison WI, Fitchburg WI, Verona WI, Mount Horeb WI, Barneveld WI, New Glarus WI, Monroe WI, Belleville WI, Oregon WI, Stoughton WI, Darlington WI, Cuba City WI, Hazel Green WI, Belmont WI, Dubuque IA, Freeport IL

Want to share this blog post? Click the links below!

Register for Monthly Newsletter